I have to start by saying that this book is HUGE - and at times I was rather discouraged and frustrated. But as I persevered and eventually made it through I realized that it was worth the read and a book that I am grateful I brought into my life.
Truthfully, there are just too many great moments to share, so I decided that I would share my 5 favorite moments of the book and the musical. Did I mention that I went to see the musical? Yes! Yesterday - the same day that I finished the book. So, while most of my adventure came through the book, it was still a wonderful ending to be able and watch the musical with all it's heart wrenching music. Without further ado...here are my top moments.
1. Fantine. Not necessarily Fantine as a whole, but her motherly instinct to put her child first. Every decision she makes is based on her child and how she can support Cosette. As she sells her hair, I was upset - as she sells her teeth I was bawling. I don't know that you can express the love and devotion that a mother has for her child, but Fantine's story does a wonderful job of portraying it. "This candle illuminated her countenance. It was a bloody smile. A reddish saliva soiled the corners of her lips, and she had a black hole in her mouth. The two teeth had been extracted." Broke my heart.
2. Little Gavroche. A child born of two of the most reprehensible people. Yet still he manages to portray all that is sweet and innocent in youth. He is kind, he is helpful, he is funny - all while surviving and living on the streets of Paris. His morals are perhaps not what they should be, however he has never been taught. Gavroche is youth that has yet to be molded and formed into any one type. He is still innocent. Hugo states that, "All crimes of the man begin in the vagabondage of the child." It is our responsibility to teach our children - they all start out sweet and innocent like Gavroche. It is up to us to help mold them and form them into something good. Little Gavroche died while helping others and with a song on his lips...and I do believe I threw my book across the room at this point. I just couldn't read any more of the brutality and abuse of children. I needed a break to go love on my own children. Such a precious gift from God.
3. "Bring Him Home" - Jean Valjean's feelings at the time of the barricade are vastly different between the book and the musical. In the book he doesn't much like Marius - Marius is the person that is going to take away Jean Valjean's reason for living (Cosette). However, in the musical he refers to him as the "son he might have known." Vastly different feelings, and yet I can't help but love this song. It is heart wrenching, it is tender, and it is beautiful. It was once played as prelude music at the funeral of a friend, and I have never been able to look at it the same way since. A beautiful prayer to the Lord advocating for the life of another. We all have an advocate that I'm sure prays to the Lord for each of us. Some day we will all go home to God and yet we will not die, but we will live! I think of this every time I hear this song.
4. Jean Valjean. How can you not love this character. His complete conversion to the Lord and his changing of his life. He no longer has a desire to do evil....well, I guess I can't really say that. There are times when Jean Valjean debates his options - should he turn himself in to save another, or should he keep quiet to save a town? - but in the end he always makes the choice that is most in keeping with his beliefs in God. I think the fact that he agonizes over decisions makes him more human - none of us can make large life changing decisions in the blink of an eye. They require meditation and prayer. However, the one thing I wish Valjean could have done was forgive himself. He was always forgiving others and yet he never seemed to be able to forgive himself. He felt that all the bad things that happened to him were his due because of his past. I just wish he could have fully understood the significance of the atonement and forgiven himself.
5. Philosophical Implications. This book is so full of religious and social philosophy. Not just claiming a belief in God, but living your life as a reflection of the Lord. Helping those in need. The children of the world and how they are a refection of our societies. There were tons! But two that stuck out to me are Justice vs. Grace and Freedom. Let's start with Justice vs Grace. Javert can not seem to reconcile his past beliefs of justice, justice, justice with this awakening of grace that Valjean has caused. "He held before him two paths, both equally straight, but he beheld two; and that terrified him;" In the end, he isn't able to reconcile himself to this new found path of Grace. So standing between two bridges - one leading to the Notre Dame Cathedral (Grace) and the other leading to the Palais de Justice (Justice) - Javert must give in his resignation to the Lord and he jumps.
Freedom - what does anyone want but freedom? These poor sad people wanted nothing more than freedom...and yet it was a long time coming. There was the French Revolution, then Napoleon, then a few more Bourbon Kings, another Napoleon, and then the Third Republic in 1870. That's 100 years of civil unrest - all for this little thing called freedom. : ) It made me think of my own country and our quest for freedom. It made me realize how lucky we were as a country. The timing was right and the location was perfect for our own revolution. Truly, had we been in England trying to break free it never would have happened. Freedom. It's programed into our souls. We will forever be seeking it for ourselves and for others.
Those are my 5. I know that there are so many other moments and ideas and concepts that could be expanded on, but these were just a few of my favorites. I really did like Eponine - in the book and the show. I was disappointed in Cosette and Marius, but they are more likable in the show. Lots and lots of things to talk about but I have to stop somewhere.
An amazing experience!
3 comments:
Never read the book. Props to you! But I can agree that Bring Him Home is hands down my favorite song. Here's my favorite version of it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaI9BPKhExk
I cried reading your post not only because I share all of your discussion points and it was wonderfully written - perfect quotes, too - but because Les Miserables is still so fresh on my mind and in my heart. I haven't been able to start reading anything else since I finished the book because I'm afraid nothing will be able to compare. Our next author has some big shoes to fill.
I've never read the book but I've loved the musical! First saw it when I was a jr in high school. Loved your post and your thoughts on the book and musical. Well done!! Maybe I'll attempt the book someday!
Post a Comment